For years, criminal groups from New York City have entered Long Island to carry out financial crimes, particularly targeting high-end jewelry stores. Instead of prioritizing these cases, DA Anne Donnelly has failed to take decisive action, allowing repeat offenders to continue operating with little consequence. Worse, her office has been accused of prosecutorial misconduct, withholding key evidence and failing to act in the interest of Long Island business owners.
A Legal System That Fails to Protect Businesses
Luxury jewelry and watch dealers rely on a fair and functioning legal system to protect them from financial crime. Yet, many business owners in Nassau County have found themselves facing legal battles not only against criminals but against a DA’s office that refuses to act in their favor.
One of the most shocking examples is the case of Jacob Avital, a well-respected jewelry buyer with a 50-year family history in the business. When Ariel Zirkiyev attempted to sell him an inauthentic Cartier bracelet, Avital immediately identified the issue. What followed was a baseless legal case against Avital and his family, despite clear evidence that they were the victims of an attempted crime.
Rather than prosecuting those who exploit businesses, DA Anne Donnelly went after the wrong people—while withholding key evidence that could have proven the truth.
Justice in NY Investigates DA Donnelly’s Misconduct
According to Justice in NY, Donnelly’s office failed to disclose critical evidence for months, all while keeping felony charges over Avital and his family. Even when the case fell apart, her office offered violations instead of dismissing the case outright, refusing to acknowledge the misconduct behind the prosecution.
Meanwhile, individuals from New York City continue to exploit Long Island businesses, knowing that weak prosecution allows them to avoid consequences. With no action from the DA’s office, these crimes continue unchecked, putting honest business owners at risk.
Why DA Donnelly Must Be Held Accountable
Nassau County businesses deserve a DA who prosecutes criminals—not business owners. Instead of protecting the community, DA Anne Donnelly has engaged in prosecutorial misconduct, pursued bogus charges, and allowed real criminals to continue operating.
It’s time for accountability.
To learn more about how DA Donnelly’s office has failed to protect Long Island businesses, visit Justice in NY and stay informed on the fight for justice.
